On the immorality of labelling other Catholics as “radical traditionalists”

"A little historical awareness, humility, respect and basic human kindness would go a long way." Image: David Gilbert Wright, 'Queuing for Holy Communion at the top of the mountain.' This article is an expanded excerpt from our essay What does Michael Lofton mean by “tradition”? In order to address this topic, we have to remember …

Continue reading On the immorality of labelling other Catholics as “radical traditionalists”

What is Theology? With a review of Mgr Joseph Clifford Fenton ‘What is Sacred Theology?’

"What can we say as we survey the smithereens of this 'Catholic intellectual landscape?'" “The strong adherence to God which alone can save our people demands the full force of revealed teaching on our life in God. The weak and emotional pietism which is expressed by some non-theological books of devotion is not enough.” Fenton, …

Continue reading What is Theology? With a review of Mgr Joseph Clifford Fenton ‘What is Sacred Theology?’

What is the state of a Catholic who submits to a “false magisterium”?

"In the moral order, the species of an act is not constituted by that which is accidental." Having established an understanding of how Louis Cardinal Billot explains heresy and membership in an earlier part, I am continuing to address some objections that frequently arise. It's fair to note that the title of this piece somewhat begs the …

Continue reading What is the state of a Catholic who submits to a “false magisterium”?

The Apostolicity of the Church – The source of ordinary jurisdiction

"Does jurisdiction flow like a river from a spring – such that if the spring stops, so does the river?" Photo by Cédric Dhaenens on Unsplash Series Introduction In this series, we are considering whether the illegitimacy of Francis and his recent predecessors would necessarily entail the disappearance of the Church’s hierarchy as a whole. …

Continue reading The Apostolicity of the Church – The source of ordinary jurisdiction